Despite the recent multitude of highly publicized elementary and high school bullying cases, bullying occurs in the adult world too. Adult bullies do their dirty work everywhere. They even demean and bully their victims in a professional environment.
Bullying in the Nursing Profession
Bullying represents a particular problem in the nursing profession, a pervasive and growing problem within the health care infrastructure. According to the JournalofNursingManagement, nurse bullying involves: the undermining of work, continual criticism, fabrication of complaints, verbal abuse, isolation of the individual, interference with work practices, and the lowering of confidence. Bullying typically occurs within the peer group. In other words, the supervisors and doctors don’t usually bully nurses — nurses bully each other.
Nurses Eat Their Young
Registered nurse Theresa Brown explains in an article from TheNewYorkTimes that “Nurses eat their young. The expression is standard lore among nurses, and it means bullying, harassment, whatever you want to call it. It’s that harsh, sometimes abusive treatment of new nurses that is entrenched on some hospital floors and schools of nursing.” This practically institutionalized behavior represents the bullies’ carefully designed scheme to subjugate inexperienced nurses to their more experienced peers.
Many young nurses enter the field because of their supportive, caring natures and they get the brunt of the painful bullying.
Cheryl Woelfle and Ruth McCaffrey speculate that this bullying emerges because “nurses often lack autonomy, accountability, and control over their profession, [which] can often result in displaced and self-destructive aggression within the oppressed group.”
While this behavior directly affects bullied nurses, it also inadvertently affects a nurse’s patients as well. Witnessing fighting between nurses can cause a patient stress, bewilderment, and agitation. Patients can also become the victims of bullying, too; frustrated nurses will sometimes badger them about their symptoms or medication, treat them roughly (e.g. careless IV placement), or ignore them when they are in need. Thus, nurse bullying isn’t just a problem that affects nurses; it affects the whole hospital.
Deal With Nurse Bullying Immediately
How do you prevent or deal with nurse bullying if you, as a nurse, experience it? Registered nurse Debra Wood has some suggestions. She suggests that nurses should avoid becoming victimized by immediately bringing the issue of bullying to the attention of supervisors or the administration. Explaining the detrimental effects of their actions to the bully may help, as a few bullies may not realize the impact of their attitudes and behavior. Sadly though, most bullies know exactly what they’re doing and have a planned agenda.
Wood also notes that one goal of any anti-bullying campaign should include changing unit culture (the code of conduct within the community of nurses). Nurse supervisors and team leads can accomplish this by having talks or discussions about the issue of bullying in the community, drafting a list of unacceptable behavior, and acting proactively by remaining positive and helpful.
Want more on nurse bullying? Check out Don’t Ya Wish You Had a BSN Like Me?
About the Author: Erica Moss currently works as community manager for Georgetown University’s online Masters degree in nursing, offering one of the nation’s leading womens health nurse practitioner programs. Outside of work, Erica enjoys photography and meeting new people.
Image credit: monroescoop dot com









#1 by ebentley on July 6, 2012 - 6:39 PM
Thank you for this! We actually address this topic in new hire orientation. I am working to start a New Grad Residency program and this is one of my concerns. We recruit the best but then we need to have the right culture.
#2 by Samantha Gluck on July 6, 2012 - 7:56 PM
It’s a terrible problem within the professional nursing community and most health care facilities sweep it under the rug, leaving the bully to continue spreading discord and endangering quality of care. Thanks for stopping by. I’m so glad you found it useful. There are a couple of other nurse bullying stories in the “nursing” category here on MTW. One of them includes first hand accounts from nurses I interviewed about their experiences.
#3 by ebentley on July 6, 2012 - 6:40 PM
Reblogged this on first person: Nurse Leader and commented:
zero tolerance for nurse bullying? Consider yourself a leader or future leader.
#4 by Samantha Gluck on July 6, 2012 - 8:07 PM
I agree. The more experienced, higher credentialed nurses should mentor the newer ones with lower degrees and motivate them to move ahead!
#5 by Stacey Turnure on July 10, 2012 - 1:22 PM
Thank you for your post. The more we talk about this issue, the more likely it is that we will arrive at a solution.
Sadly, a shameful culture of incivility (one in which bullying can exist) infects most healthcare workplaces. It leaves healthcare workers feeling exhausted, hopeless and dissatisfied. It chases good people away from the field at a time when we need them the most. But that’s not even the worst part. Incivility amongst healthcare employees leads to more medical errors, dissatisfied patients and higher healthcare costs for us all.
The problem of incivility is so serious that The Joint Commission recently issued new regulations on reporting, disciplining and preventing such situations in healthcare environments
A fellow nurse and I have written a book and are developing a civility training resource that addresses all these issues. It’s called “The REAL Healthcare Reform.” We believe real reform goes beyond politics. Real reform lies in reversing the culture of incivility.
Please, feel free to contact me personally if you’d like more information about this resource. I can be reached at staceyturnure@knowingmore.com
#6 by Samantha Gluck on July 10, 2012 - 3:30 PM
Hi Stacey,
I’m actually very interested in knowing more and will email you later on today after I catch up with client work.
You’re right, a culture of incivility has reigned for far too long in our health care facilities. I find it curious that nurses bully each other. One might think that doctors bully nurses, but this is rarely the case (exceptions noted).
We must find a way to get at its core rather than just treating surface symptoms and causes.